Cause Analysis of Falling Accident of a High-Altitude Installation of a Grid Truss
-
摘要: 某项目顶盖采用了两边支承的正放四角锥网架,在高空安装过程中突然坠落,造成多人死伤的重大安全事故。为了探究该网架坠落的原因,减少此类大跨空间钢结构事故的再次发生,采用“假设原因—理论分析—模型验证”的方法,首先通过现场调查,结合项目设计文件、施工次序以及受力分析,对网架坠落原因提出如下三种推断:1)高空散拼过程中,网架悬挑延伸部分的自重和施工荷载施加到已完成的板带上,导致已完成的边跨板带超载;2)网架上弦未与钢柱连接,钢柱顶底均为铰接,门式刚架体系不成立,整体结构为机构;3)上弦端部节点未有效连接,竖向荷载通过截面较小的竖腹杆传递,传力路径与网架施工图不符。其次为验证以上推断,采用空间钢结构分析软件3D3S建立网架施工模拟有限元模型,模型边界条件、施工步与实际相同,分析施工过程中网架竖向变形及支座处竖腹杆的轴力变化情况。结果表明:施工方案改变了网架的传力路径,施工过程中支座处竖腹杆轴力远超其稳定承载力,受压屈曲丧失支承能力,导致网架整体坠落。最后基于事故的惨痛教训及空间结构成型过程的复杂性,对空间结构施工模拟分析的必要性进行探讨,指出施工模拟分析能够体现构件逐次安装、支座约束状态变化以及荷载的施加次序,是一次虚拟建造的过程,不仅能发现施工方案的缺陷和风险,还能发现施工次序带来的与一次成型结构不同的构件内力与变形偏差,供结构工程师与施工方案设计师对比,评判其差异是否在可接受的范围内,以确保施工方案的安全性与合理性。Abstract: A significant safety incident occurred during the installation of a two-sided supported regular quadrangular pyramid-shaped grid truss in a project, resulting in multiple fatalities and injuries. To investigate the cause of the grid truss fall and reduce the recurrence of similar long-span spatial steel structure accidents, the methodology of “hypothesized causes-theoretical analysis-model verification” was adopted. Firstly, through on-site investigations and in conjunction with project design documents, construction sequence, and structural analysis, the following three hypotheses regarding the cause of the grid truss collapse were proposed: 1) during the high-altitude piece-by-piece assembly process, the self-weight and construction load of the cantilevered extension section of the grid structure were imposed on the completed edge strip, causing the completed edge strip to be overloaded; 2) the upper chord of the grid truss was not connected to the steel column, and both the top and bottom of the steel column were hinged, invalidating the portal frame system and rendering the overall structure unstable; 3) the effective connection between the end joints of the upper chord was not established, and the vertical load was transmitted through the smaller vertical web rod, deviating from the construction drawing of the grid truss. Secondly, to validate the above hypotheses, a finite element model for the construction simulation of the grids truss was established using the spatial steel structure analysis software 3D3S. The boundary conditions, construction steps, and actual circumstances of the model were identical. The analysis of the vertical deformation and axial force variations of the support column during the construction process of the grid truss was carried out. The results indicated that the construction scheme altered the load transfer path of the grid truss, and the axial force on the support column during the construction process far exceeded its stable bearing capacity, causing the column to buckle under compression and lose its supporting capacity, which resulted in the overall collapse of the grid truss. Finally, based on the tragic lessons learned from the accident and considering the complexity of forming spatial structures, the necessity of conducting construction simulation analysis was emphasized. It was pointed out that such analysis, which constitutes a virtual construction process, can replicate the sequential installation of components, the evolution of support constraints, and the order of load application. This process not only helps identify defects and risks in the construction scheme but also reveals deviations in the internal forces and deformations of components, which are caused by the construction sequence and differ from those in a monolithically formed structure. These insights allow structural engineers to collaborate with construction designers, compare results, and determine whether the deviations are acceptable, thereby ensuring the safety and rationality of the construction scheme.
-
Key words:
- grids truss /
- high-altitude installation /
- falling accident /
- construction simulation
-
[1] 陈骥. 美国哈特福德城体育馆网架结构失稳事故分析[J]. 钢结构,1997,12(4):20-25. [2] 姜丽云,刘锡良. 天津某网架工程事故分析[J]. 空间结构,1997(1):62-64. [3] 楼昕,王凤平. 某学校风雨操场屋面网架整体坍塌事故原因分析[J]. 工程质量,2020,38(10):103-107. [4] 徐永春,王者静,王新堂. 某网架吊装坠落事故分析[J]. 施工技术,2000(8):24-26. [5] 王玉军. 某厂房球型网架坍塌事故的原因分析[J]. 建筑技术,2008(7):551-553. [6] 宋娟,罗国波,田涌,等. 某大跨度网架垮塌原因分析[C]// 2022年工业建筑学术交流会论文集(下册). 2022. [7] 宋松林,马建勋. 某大型厂房网架事故诊断与处理[J]. 建筑技术,2004(4):279-280. [8] 葛娈. 某焊接空心球网架车间坍塌事故分析[D]. 太原:太原理工大学,2014. [9] 王俊. 深圳国际展览中心网架倒塌[J]. 建筑结构,1993(12):37. [10] 郝成新,钱基宏,宋涛,等. 网架事故原因分析[J]. 工程质量,2009,27(4):61-65. [11] 程长明. 某楼面网架倒塌事故分析[J]. 建筑科学,2009,25(4):90-92. [12] 苏健. 某工程钢网架屋盖坍塌事故鉴定与分析[J]. 陕西建筑,2023(5):117-120. [13] 雷宏刚. 钢结构事故分析与处理[M]. 北京:中国建材工业出版社,2003. [14] 贾斌,李柯燃,黄友帮. 大跨斜拉空间结构预应力施工控制及监测技术[J]. 施工技术,2018,47(15):73-77. [15] 郭彦林,崔晓强. 大跨度复杂钢结构施工过程中的若干技术问题及探讨[J]. 工业建筑,2004,34(12):1-5. [16] 周观根,谢董恩,游桂模,等. 杭州奥体中心亚运三馆体育游泳馆施工关键技术[J]. 钢结构(中英文),2020,35(10):1-8. -
点击查看大图
计量
- 文章访问数: 14
- HTML全文浏览量: 3
- PDF下载量: 0
- 被引次数: 0



登录
注册
下载: